The Core Values Discovery Process: Defining Your North Star

Table of Contents

The Core Values Discovery Process: Defining Your North Star

Every organization — from a two-person startup to a global corporation — needs a North Star. Core values are that North Star: simple, memorable principles that guide decisions, behaviors, hiring, and culture. But defining them isn’t a branding exercise or a one-off workshop. It’s a discovery process that, when done well, becomes a strategic asset.

In this article you’ll get a practical, step-by-step guide to discovering your core values, tools and exercises you can use immediately, realistic budget and outcome figures, and honest pitfalls to avoid. Think of this as a friendly roadmap: clear, pragmatic, and designed to fit real-world timelines and budgets.

Why Core Values Matter

Values are more than words on a poster. They help people answer three critical questions every day:

What behavior gets rewarded here?
How do we make decisions when outcomes are uncertain?
Who belongs on this team?

According to workplace studies, companies with clearly communicated values and alignment experience:

Lower voluntary turnover rates (often by 20–40%).
Better employee engagement and higher productivity.
Faster hiring decisions and clearer performance feedback.

“Values are the operating system of culture. They’re what let people make consistent choices even when leaders aren’t in the room.” — Dr. Sara Bennett, organizational psychologist

The Core Values Discovery Process — Overview

The discovery process has six practical phases. Each phase includes activities designed to surface genuine, actionable values rather than aspirational slogans.

1. Prepare: clarify objectives and stakeholders
2. Gather input: interviews, surveys, stories
3. Synthesize: identify themes and test language
4. Validate: confirm with stakeholders and leaders
5. Implement: bake values into processes and communication
6. Measure and iterate: track alignment and outcomes

Phase 1 — Prepare: Set the Scope and Intent

Start with these questions and document your answers in a one-page brief:

Why now? (e.g., scaling, merger, poor retention)
Who needs to be involved? (leadership, cross-functional reps, HR)
What will success look like in 6 and 12 months?

Tip: Keep the steering group small (3–7 people) but intentionally diverse. Include one operational leader, one people/HR lead, and one frontline team member. That mix keeps values grounded, not aspirational.

Phase 2 — Gather Input: Stories, Data, and Sentiment

The best values come from patterns in real behavior. Use multiple input methods to surface those patterns:

One-on-one interviews (30–60 minutes) with leaders and long-tenured employees.
Anonymous survey with open-ended prompts: “Describe a moment here that made you proud,” “Where do we fall short?”
Focus groups or storytelling sessions where people share memorable work moments.
Data review — retention rates, exit interview themes, customer NPS quotes.

Example survey prompts

“Tell a story about a time someone here acted in a way you want repeated.”
“If you could change one behavior in our organization, what would it be?”

Expert note: Collect a mix of quantitative indicators (turnover numbers, engagement scores) and qualitative stories. The narratives often reveal the values-in-practice.

Phase 3 — Synthesize: Turn Stories into Thematic Values

Once you have the raw material, synthesize it into a shortlist of potential values. This phase is about pattern recognition and careful wording.

Affinity mapping: group similar stories and highlight repeat themes.
Draft value statements that include a short label (one or two words) and a brief behavioral definition.
Use examples and anti-examples: describe what living the value looks like and what it doesn’t.

Sample value format

Curiosity — We ask questions and test assumptions. Example: We run small experiments before scaling. Not: Waiting for perfect information before acting.

Keep the list tight. Aim for 3–7 core values. More than seven becomes hard to internalize.

Phase 4 — Validate: Test and Refine with Stakeholders

Validation prevents the “values by committee” problem where statements become bland and meaningless. Run these checks:

Leadership review for strategic fit.
Town hall or department sessions to gather reactions and tweak language.
Pilot hiring and performance conversations using the new language for three months.

“When people hear values and say ‘that’s literally how I want to be treated here,’ you know you’re close.” — Marcus Lee, HR director

Phase 5 — Implement: Make Values Operational

Words change behavior when embedded in processes. Key places to implement values:

Hiring — include values-based interview questions and scorecards.
Onboarding — teach examples, stories, and quick scenarios.
Performance reviews — use values as part of competency assessment.
Recognition programs — reward public examples of values lived.
Decision frameworks — add a values checkpoint for major investments.

Example values-based interview question for “Ownership”

“Tell me about a time you fixed a problem that wasn’t your direct responsibility. What did you do? What was the outcome?”

Phase 6 — Measure, Iterate, and Keep Alive

Values are living. Track whether they actually influence behavior and outcomes:

Pulse surveys (quarterly) with value alignment questions.
Retention and performance trends for teams identified as high/low value alignment.
Number of value-based recognitions recorded per month.

Sample alignment survey question: “In the last 30 days, I observed teammates acting in ways consistent with our values.” Use a 5-point Likert scale and track changes over time.

Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

Vague, aspirational phrasing: Avoid terms like “Excellence” without clear behavioral definition.
Too many values: If you list 12 values, none will stick. Keep it 3–7.
Top-down imposition: Without frontline input, values feel contrived.
No operational tie-ins: Values that don’t affect hiring, rewards, or decision-making become decorative.

Tools and Exercises You Can Use This Week

Quick exercises you can run in half a day with a small group:

Story harvest (60–90 minutes): Each person shares two stories: one proud moment, one frustrating moment. Group themes and identify language that recurs.
Inverted values (30 minutes): Ask “What behavior would make us terrible?” Flip those to find positive value language.
Values voting (15 minutes): Present 10 drafted values; each person gets 5 votes to allocate. See the top 3–5 rise to the surface.

Sample Values and Behavior Examples

Here are sample values with practical behavioral cues. Use them as starters; adapt language to your context.

Customer Obsession — We proactively solve customer problems; we measure impact and learn quickly.
Ownership — We take responsibility for outcomes, not just outputs.
Radical Candor — We share feedback directly and kindly, focused on growth.
Frugality — We seek creative, cost-effective solutions without sacrificing quality.
Continuous Learning — We reflect on failures and share lessons openly.

Estimating Cost and Impact — A Realistic Financial View

Implementing values isn’t free, but neither is doing nothing. Below are two tables with plausible budget estimates and the potential financial impact of improved alignment.

.finance-table { border-collapse: collapse; width: 100%; max-width: 750px; margin: 16px 0; font-family: Arial, sans-serif; }
.finance-table th, .finance-table td { border: 1px solid #ddd; padding: 10px; text-align: left; }
.finance-table th { background: #f7f7f7; font-weight: 600; }
.finance-table caption { font-weight: 700; margin-bottom: 8px; }
.highlight { background: #eaf7ea; }

Estimated Project Budget for Core Values Discovery (Mid-sized company, ~150 employees)
Item	Hours / Qty	Unit Cost	Estimated Total
Leadership planning & steering	40 hours	$120/hr (opportunity cost)	$4,800
Employee interviews & synthesis	120 hours (internal + facilitator)	$100/hr	$12,000
Workshops & validation sessions	3 half-day sessions	$1,500/session (external facilitator)	$4,500
Communications & rollout materials	Design + print + digital	—	$3,000
Training and onboarding updates	Internal time	—	$2,500
Total Estimated Investment			$26,800

Note: External consultants can increase costs; many companies complete most work internally for $10k–$40k, depending on scale.

Illustrative Impact: Value Alignment vs. Misalignment (Company of 150 employees)
Metric	Before (Baseline)	After (Improved Alignment)	Assumptions / Notes
Annual voluntary turnover	18% (27 employees)	12% (18 employees)	40% relative reduction in turnover
Average cost per turnover	$15,000 (recruiting, ramp, productivity loss)
Annual turnover cost	$405,000	$270,000	27 x $15k = $405k; 18 x $15k = $270k
Estimated Annual Savings			$135,000
Improved revenue from productivity (conservative)		$120,000	Small productivity gains from better alignment
Net Annual Benefit (approx.)			$255,000

Interpretation: With an estimated project cost of ~$26,800 and a potential annual benefit of approximately $255,000, the payback can occur within months. Of course, results vary by context and execution quality.

Mini Case Study — 90-Day Example

Acme Tech (hypothetical) is a 220-person B2B product company. They had 22% turnover and a culture described in exit interviews as “fast but inconsistent.” Over 90 days they:

Conducted 40 interviews and a company-wide survey (response rate 78%).
Ran three synthesis workshops and drafted five core values.
Piloted values-based hiring in two teams (sales, product).

Outcomes after 12 months

Turnover dropped from 22% to 14% — estimated savings: $240,000.
Time-to-hire decreased from 38 days to 30 days for roles using values-based scorecards.
Employee NPS improved from 6 to 22.

“The difference was in the conversations. Once we had language, managers could coach and hire with clarity.” — Priya Natarajan, Head of People, Acme Tech

How to Write Actionable Value Statements

Good value statements have three parts:

The label (1–2 words)
A behavioral definition (a sentence)
Examples and anti-examples (short bullet points)

Example

Label: Collaborative Ownership
Definition: We share responsibility for outcomes and help each other meet shared goals.
Example: A product manager stays until a critical customer issue is resolved, even if not directly assigned.
Anti-example: “That’s not my job” responses to cross-team issues.

Measuring Success — KPIs and Signals

Quantitative KPIs

Turnover rate (overall and voluntary)
Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS)
Time-to-hire and offer acceptance rates
Number of value-based recognitions / month

Qualitative signals

Stories from onboarding cohorts: do new hires recount value-aligned moments?
Manager feedback on whether values help in performance conversations.
Customer feedback that hints at consistent brand behavior (e.g., responsiveness).

Final Checklist: Launching Your Core Values Project

Set scope, timeline (8–12 weeks for discovery + 3–6 months rollout).
Create a small, diverse steering group.
Collect stories through interviews and surveys.
Synthesize to 3–7 value statements with behaviors.
Validate with the company and iterate language.
Embed values in hiring, onboarding, and performance processes.
Measure alignment quarterly and share results transparently.

Parting Thoughts

Defining core values is a strategic investment that goes beyond language. When values are authentic, practiced, and operationalized, they reduce friction, speed decisions, and create a shared understanding of what matters. The discovery process is the step where you transform culture from a vague aspiration into a practical, measurable force.

Start small, center real stories, and iterate. As one leader put it:

“Values lose their power when they’re posted instead of practiced. The discovery process is where practice begins.” — Elena Rios, Chief People Officer

Ready to get started? Run a 90-minute story harvest with your team this week, and you’ll be surprised how quickly recurring patterns reveal your true North Star.

Source: